Letter from the
Center for Biological Diversity
A 2010 letter from Center for Biological Diversity staff attorney Brent Plater urging full protection for the coral reef at Great Guana Cay from the proposed Bakers Bay development.
Updated August 31, 2026
The Center for Biological Diversity is a US-based environmental nonprofit founded in 1989, known for using scientific petitions and litigation to win protections for endangered species. Brent Plater was a staff attorney with the organization at the time of this 2010 letter, writing to flag that the proposed Bakers Bay Golf & Ocean Club development did not adequately guard against nutrient runoff and other threats to the coral reef at Guana Cay.
I am writing you today to request that you provide full protection for the coral reef at Guana Cay. Corals in the Caribbean have suffered extraordinary declines in abundance and face significant threats, including global warming, nutrient runoff, and disease. Indeed, the only Caribbean corals in the genus Acropora have declined by more than 97% in every location where systematic studies have been conducted. Unfortunately the threats the species currently face are systemic, difficult to manage, and affect every nautical mile of their habitat simultaneously.
It is critically important that development near coral reefs ensure that reef ecosystems are not perturbed. This means, among other constraints, that nutrient runoff from existing golf courses and similar developments be reduced and new sources of runoff be prevented. The proposal for development at Guana Cay by the Discovery Land Company does not provide adequate assurance that reef ecosystems in the area will be protected from harm, and would likely lead to degradation of the reef ecosystem at the Cay.
Brent Plater
Staff Attorney
Center for Biological Diversity
http://www.biologicaldiversity.org